What Kind of Thing is Art?
This essay reviews two publications that center on the agency of visual culture in shaping modern life and subjectivity in 1950-70s Lebanon. Rooted in cultural anthropology, Zeina Maasri’s Cosmopolitan Radicalism: The Visual Politics of Beirut’s Global Sixties (2020) and Kirsten Scheid’s Fantasmic Objects: Art and Sociality from Lebanon, 1920-1950 (2022) depart from poststructuralist models of visual studies, emphasizing instead the concrete materiality and affective strength of the art object—print matter in the former; the imaginal process of becoming modern through an artistic encounter in the latter—over its legibility as a text. The review delineates the challenges the two publications pose to the pervasive positivism in Middle East Studies while also analyzing their failure (or refusal) to account for the social genesis that lends art its peculiar ontological status as both a commodity and an autonomous thing.
ARTMargins, Volume 14, Issue 1, pp. 132-146.
doi:10.1162/artm_r_00403
https://direct.mit.edu/artm/article/14/1/132/130980/What-Kind-of-Thing-is-Art
Content for this article is available at MIT Press. It is available as: No Access/Subscription Only . Click here for more information.



